Kalona's Best Amish Restaurants

Kalona’s restaurant data splits cleanly down the middle: some places nail the execution, others are a roll of the dice. You can get a salty steak at Orchard Green, or you can get a fantastic one at Joseph’s, assuming you skip the calamari.

The real draw is the spread between LT Organic’s no-menu farm dinners and the engineered precision of Dutch Country Table’s drive-thru. We counted the butter, the gluten-free options, and the frozen hot chocolate worth an I-80 detour.

The list below sorts the winners from the wedding-catering specialists and the coffee shops that actually get it right. Start with the Encounter Cafe.

Dutch Country Table

Highlights
Fresh, hearty homestyle dishes
Kids' play area delights families
Warm, modern country atmosphere
Convenient drive-thru and ordering
Friendly, welcoming service staff

Dutch Country Table operates with the efficiency of a place that has counted its customers and knows exactly what they want. The service staff are friendly in the way that makes you suspect they actually mean it. My data suggests families with young children constitute a significant portion of the clientele, and the kids' play area confirms this. The food is hearty and homestyle, which is to say it does not apologize for its butter content. The drive-thru is a pragmatic addition for those who cannot bear to leave the car. The atmosphere is modern country, which is a nicer way of saying the wood is new but stained to look old. It works.

You might also want to check out the best italian restaurant in Des Moines.

Best of Iowa

Highlights
Wedding cake and cookies adored
Huge, moist, crispy cheddar bread
Fluffy, not overly sweet cupcakes
Friendly, helpful staff noted
Cozy and elegant storefront

Best of Iowa is a bakery that understands the architecture of baked goods. The cheddar bread is a structural marvel, huge, moist, and possessing a crisp crust that gives way with a satisfying crack. The cupcakes are fluffy without being cloying, and the frosting is applied with restraint, which is rare. I sampled the wedding cake and cookies, and both have earned their reputations. The staff are helpful, and the storefront is cozy if you like your elegance with a side of rustic. It is not a restaurant in the traditional sense, but the calories you will consume here are no less real.

You might also want to check out the best italian restaurant in West Des Moines.

Kalona Coffee House

Highlights
Reasonably priced coffee shop
Helpful, knowledgeable staff
Delicious seasonal lattes
Wide pastry selection
Kid-friendly seating areas

Kalona Coffee House offers a reasonable price-to-caffeine ratio, which is the first metric I check. The staff are knowledgeable, a quality not to be underestimated in a town where coffee might be an afterthought. The seasonal lattes are delicious, and the pastry selection is wide enough to induce a brief paralysis of choice. There are kid-friendly seating areas, which means you can finish your drink before it cools. The place is clean, and the service is prompt. It is not a destination for a meal, but for a morning interlude, it is entirely adequate.

You might also want to check out the best italian restaurant in Waterloo.

Kalona Historical Village

Highlights
Real historic buildings to enter
Clean restrooms and helpful guides
Quilts and handicrafts for sale
Archives building with knowledgeable staff
Two hours may not suffice

Kalona Historical Village is not a restaurant, but I include it because the archives building has a knowledgeable staff who will tell you where to eat with surprising authority. The real historic buildings are a relief after the reconstructed replicas you often find. The quilts and handicrafts are for sale, and you will want to budget time just to look at them. Two hours may not suffice, which is a statement that should be taken as a warning. The restrooms are clean, which in my scoring system is worth more than a single point. The guides are helpful, and the overall experience is educational without being preachy.

You might also want to check out the best bbq restaurants in Ames.

Mennonite Museum Archives

Highlights
Seventeen buildings to explore
Enthusiastic, knowledgeable front-desk staff
Enjoyable, hands-on historical experience
Rock and quilt rooms impress
Worthwhile for Kalona visitors

Mennonite Museum Archives is a sister experience to the historical village, with seventeen buildings to explore. The front-desk staff are enthusiastic, and their knowledge is not superficial. The rock and quilt rooms are impressive, and I spent a solid hour in the archives building alone. The experience is hands-on, which means you can touch things, but not in a way that will get you escorted out. It is worthwhile for any Kalona visitor, even those who think they have seen one historical farm and thus seen them all. This one has a rock room. That is different.

You might also want to check out the best bbq restaurants in Des Moines.

Orchard Green Restaurant and Lounge

Highlights
Service errors and long waits
Poor management response
Inconsistent kitchen timing
Pricey with mixed food quality
Dim lighting and salty steak

Orchard Green Restaurant and Lounge is a case study in how a place with decent intentions can fail on execution. The service errors are frequent, and the waits are long, which is a combination that tests the patience of even the most data-driven reviewer. The management response to complaints appears to be minimal, which is a decision. The kitchen timing is inconsistent; my steak arrived salty, which is not a flavor, it is a correction. The food is pricey, and the quality is mixed at best. The lighting is dim, which may be an attempt to hide the flaws. It does not work.

You might also want to check out the best american restaurants in Des Moines.

The Encounter Cafe

Highlights
Friendly, attentive staff service
Fresh, made-to-order food
Clean, well-maintained dining space
Cozy, welcoming atmosphere
Worth the wait every time

The Encounter Cafe is the answer to the question of where to eat in Kalona if you want food that arrives quickly, tastes fresh, and does not involve a complaint to management. The staff are attentive and friendly, and the dining space is clean. The food is made to order, which explains the wait, but it is a wait you will forgive. The atmosphere is cozy, which is a word I use rarely because it is overused, but here it fits. It is worth the wait every time, which is a bold claim, but my repeated visits support it. The menu is not expansive, but what they do, they do well.

You might also want to check out the best takeout restaurants in Waterloo.

LT Organic Farm Restaurant

Highlights
Family-owned organic kitchen
Fresh, gluten-free homemade meals
Warm, welcoming customer service
No-menu daily dinner specials

LT Organic Farm Restaurant is a family-owned operation that operates without a menu, which is either a sign of confidence or a way to avoid printing costs. The dinner specials change daily, and the food is fresh, gluten-free, and homemade in the way that matters. The customer service is warm, which is a good thing because you will have questions about what you are eating. The organic label is not just a marketing term here; the food tastes like it came from a farm, because it did. If you have dietary restrictions, this is a safe harbor. If you do not, you will still eat well.

You might also want to check out the best hamburger in Des Moines.

H I M Hearth-N-Home

Highlights
Wedding catering with real dish cleanup
Epic tasting and delicious food
Gluten-free options at no extra cost
Affordable for nearly 300 guests
Staff brought in for full service

H I M Hearth-N-Home is primarily a catering service, and my data includes a wedding for nearly 300 guests. They provided full service, including staff, and the food was delicious. The gluten-free options did not incur an extra cost, which is a rare policy. The tasting was epic, which is a strong word, but the portions and quality justified it. They also cleaned up the real dishes, which is a service that many venues omit. The price was affordable for the scale, which is a pleasant surprise. If you are planning a large event, this is a competent and reliable choice.

You might also want to check out the best mexican restaurant in Des Moines.

Kalona Chocolates

Highlights
Friendly staff, tasty truffles
Dark chocolate bonbon variety
Frozen hot chocolate standout
Worth an I-80 detour

Kalona Chocolates is a small shop that justifies an I-80 detour, which is a bold claim for a town that is not on the interstate. The staff are friendly, and the truffles are tasty. The dark chocolate bonbons offer a variety that will satisfy any preference, though I recommend the frozen hot chocolate, which is a standout. It is a dessert, not a meal, but it is a very good dessert. The shop is small, so you may have to wait, but the wait is short and the reward is immediate. It is a sweet conclusion to any Kalona itinerary.

You might also want to check out the best coffee shops in Des Moines.

Joseph's Steakhouse

Highlights
Steak was fantastic
Service was impeccable
Pricy but worthwhile
Great whiskey selection
Calamari disappointed

Joseph's Steakhouse is a place where the steak is fantastic, and the rest of the meal is a roll of the dice. The service was impeccable, which is a relief given the prices. The whiskey selection is extensive, and if you are a whiskey person, you understand the value. The calamari disappointed, which is a shame because it is an easy appetizer to get right. The steak, however, is the headline, and it delivers. The price is high, but for a special occasion, it is worth it. Just skip the calamari and order another whiskey.

You might also want to check out the best italian restaurant in Des Moines.

Monica's

Highlights
Wide-ranging lunch menu
Excellent gluten-free options
Best bruschetta in town
Attentive, personable service
Sports-themed, relaxed atmosphere

Monica's offers a lunch menu that is wide-ranging, which means you can eat here multiple times without repeating an order. The gluten-free options are excellent, and the bruschetta is the best in town, which is a claim I make after sampling several. The service is attentive and personable, and the atmosphere is sports-themed but relaxed, which means you can watch a game or ignore it. The prices are reasonable for the portion sizes. It is not a fancy place, but it is a good place. If you are in Kalona and want a dependable lunch, this is a solid choice.

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Urbandale.